free hit counters

Dose of Truth Serum: How to REALLY Rate Hookups


I conceived a more honest hookup scale back in 2003. We were living in a Golden Age back then: Diddy was still Puff Daddy, the Razor was the coolest phone in the world, fat chicks were required to wear Hannibal Lector masks over their pudgy faces when appearing in public. A rip-roaring era indeed, my friends and I oft found ourselves at the local coed watering hole, under the subterfuge of fake I.D.s, trying to get our proverbial mack on.

DSC01527One night, we caught one of our friends “hollering” at a corpulent wench way below his normal standards, yet far above the weight capacity for most buses. We watched in horror as the specter of Bacchus incited our friend to serenade said fatso with a slurred rendition of “Shake Ya Tailfeather”; however, it seemed more appropriate he sing, “Flap Ya Whale-fin”.

But hey, I don’t judge. I don’t make superficial judgments based on who goes home with what at the end of the night. In fact, by my logic, for every dude hooking up with a fatty, that’s one less fatty hooking up with me. So my friend’s encounter with a creature of the bovine kind did not personally offend me – until “Tall Tale Sunday” rolled around. Like clockwork, we followed every drunken weekend with a day of retrospection as my friends and I gathered in the dining hall to recall in lucid detail the thrill of victory and the agony of going home alone to masturbate.

That Sunday, I waited with bated breath for my friend’s extra large account. But robbing us of cheap laughs at his expense, he claimed he’d hooked up with a “solid 8” the night prior. We all stared at him in disbelief. I offered counsel, assuring him all of us have waken up the morning after a sweet bender, under the impression we snatched something pretty, only to learn we hooked up with someone’s dad. But when it happens, we don’t prance around like he/she/it was a hot number. That’s not cool. No one’s ADD will sit through such fables…

No. The next morning with your buddies is “Show and Tell” and if you put on an embarrassing “show,” you’re required a truthful “tell.” When my friend indignantly insisted the girl he’d gotten busy with was “really an 8…maybe a 7.5 without makeup”, I forgave him for I realized he knows not what he does.

It wasn’t his fault he’s retarded – it was the system’s. Gauging hookups via a numerical classification is wack. The 1-10 scale fluctuates like the weight of a bulimic sumo wrestler and is about as reliable as a nymphomaniac girlfriend. There’s simply no quality control. One man’s “8” is another man’s “MY GOD!  WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED LAST NIGHT?!” which, for Michael Jackson (RIP), is a child under the age of 8.  Therefore, I implemented a candid five-fold assessment scale ranging from the compulsive lie (The Impossible Dream) down to the most embarrassing moment of your life (The Vietnam Flashback).


1. The Impossible Dream

The world is broken into two groups: those that have never hooked up with anyone in this category, and those who have lied about it. This category encompasses the Helen of Troys, the babester babes, the crème de la femmes. The only civilians who snag these resplendent beings are those who do so with help from a wingman with the first name “Roof” and last name “fies”.


2. Goin’ for the Gold


These are the girls who’ve been on your “To Do” list since the late ‘80s.  A lofty endeavor indeed, bringing one’s “A-Game” is a prerequisite. Not only must you clock in long man-hours of tedious conversation and feigned laughter but the selfless sacrifice of friends and wingmen are just as crucial as they divert potential “haters” and “cock blocks” from blowing up your spot. With a bit of luck and a lot of game (read: drinks for her), you may find yourself “standing” one sweet night.  Fittingly, the next day should find you with a megaphone broadcasting your glorious exploit to the immediate world.


3. Middle Earth

You decided to play it safe.  While it was nothing to write home about, it was nothing to enter the witness protection program over either.


4. The Blooper Reel

Ouch. Maybe you were running selfless interference for a friend, and while he was busy groping someone higher on this scale you were sucking the face off something nasty. Still, as gross as aforesaid beast was, you can still look back with friends and laugh over it. When someone says, “Remember the manimal with the missing teeth you made out with?? Hahahahaha!!”  You will still be able to squeak out a meek “Ha.”

5. A Vietnam Flashback

The hookup you never want to relive: No matter how much alcohol was consumed, no matter how forced or comatose you were at the time, there is no excuse for a ‘Nam Flashback.  Would you ever want to relive Charlie gutting your best bud right in front of your eyes?  Well, the same goes for a monster that falls into this category. The memory will haunt your nightmares and wake you in a cold sweat FOREVER.

In conclusion, don’t rob hecklers of potential laughs at your expense. If you find yourself on the wrong end of something hideous, be honest with yourself and admit it was a “blooper”. Like the chubby chick with the midriff tube top, don’t cover it up. When your buzz rubs off, and “Cinderella” turns into something that belongs in a cage at midnight, remember this article!

About Rob J.

Rob J. is a writer and dating instructor in New York City. Themes that resonate in both his teaching and writing are masculinity, genuineness, rational self-interest, and general awesomeness.

We respect your email privacy


  1. Sin

    July 22, 2009 at 1:15 pm

    Your a douche 😉 love the post hit me up brother

  2. Johnny Whiteshoes

    July 22, 2009 at 3:14 pm

    Well said! I was watching a video in which the chicks Mystery and his henchmen were pulling in were categorized as 8s and 9s… This was a fail if I’ve ever seen one. Try 5s or 6s if we’re going off of the definition instilled by them.

    Anyways, just found this video as well. It’s is hilarious!

  3. Bobby Rio

    July 22, 2009 at 3:47 pm

    Nice post.

    I wish fat girls were still required to wear hanibal masks…

    And god,

    I have one or two of those flashback hookups… i literally want to shower every time i think of them…


  4. Rob Judge

    July 22, 2009 at 4:05 pm

    Haaaaa…lovin’ these baller responses.

    I hope karma isn’t a fat chick or I’m fucked!

    btw everyone has at lease one Nam Flashback in their closet..whatevs, she looked ok at the time…

  5. Adonis

    July 22, 2009 at 4:16 pm

    In that case, I hit the “blooper reel” recently… The grenades I will jump on some my students can get some prime, but if he’s reading this comment he will know what I mean when I say “GLAZED DONUT!”

  6. PeteTheFreshman

    July 22, 2009 at 5:49 pm

    LOL @ Middle Earth

    My roommate in college would hook up with so my middle earth level girls that we spray painted “Gates of Mordor” on the door of our room

  7. Pingback: Your Weekly Mantelligence Briefing for July 23rd | Just A Guy Thing

  8. S.P.E.S.H.

    July 23, 2009 at 7:17 pm

    all about the ternary scale: 0 (wouldn’t fuck), 1 (would fuck), 2 (would fuck and show photos to my friends).. the 1-10 scale is fucking retarded 😛 good article tho, enjoyed the language

  9. Hammer

    July 24, 2009 at 10:56 am

    I have a similar scale to SPESH. A 0, 1, 2 scale. 0 is a “No,” 1 is a “Yes, but not LTR material” and a 2 is “Yes, and hot enough to be my girlfriend”. Keep in mind that just because a girl is a 2 doesn’t mean she’s LTR material, but it does mean that she achieves minimum standard in the looks department.

    I would never have sex with a woman who I was afraid to show. That said, even if I did, I wouldn’t be afraid to show it, so it’s sort of a moot point, but my personal standards are high enough that it doesn’t get to that point.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login