Is The Morning The Best Time To Do Cardio For Fat Loss?
There are a lot of different ideas as to when the optimal time to do cardio is. Many swear by performing cardio first thing in the morning while others feel it is important to consume complex carbohydrates a few hours before aerobic exercise.
This answer will depend on your goal and your preferences.
If your goal is fat loss, then performing cardio first thing in the morning may be the be a good method of action.
In 1985, a study was conducted at the University of Kansas showing that performing cardiovascular exercise early in the morning caused much greater fat loss than aerobic exercise performed in the evening.
In another study performed at Kansas State University, published in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, showed similar results as the study performed at the University of Kansas.
In the study, caloric expenditure, and the percentage burned from fat and carbohydrates was measured. The results of the study showed that almost 70% of the calories burned during cardio after a 12 hour fast was fat. Only 50% of the calories burned after exercise was fat for the group who exercised after eating later in the day.
Another study conducted in Belgium had 3 groups. The study lasted 6 weeks. One group performed high-intensity running and cycling in the morning in a fasted state. Another group did not exercise at all. The final group engaged in high-intensity cycling and running later in the day.
All of the three groups were all also put on a diet in which calorie intake was increased, and this diet was very high in fat. The results of the study showed that the group who exercised later in the day gained more weight than those who exercised in the fasted state in the morning.
The group who exercised in the morning also experienced adaptations in muscle and experienced improved whole-body glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity.
A study published in the Journal of Sports Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism compared fat metabolism during training in the fasted state versus training after eating. Each subject consumed the same Mediterranean-style breakfast. They also consumed the same amount of calories in the 24 hours following exercise.
In the twelve hours after exercise, the VO2 was higher in the fed subjects, and the respiratory exchange rate was lower in the fed subjects. These complicated words imply that there was a greater use of fats in the fed group.
The study concluded that when moderate exercise is conducted to lose body fat, working out in the fasted state does not burn fat better than working out in the fed state.
Like with so many topics in the realm of fitness and nutrition, there is no black-and-white answer.
Exercising in the fasted state may have a positive impact on fat loss. However, none of the studies I found that showed that cardiovascular exercise resulted in greater fat loss measured fat loss 24 hours after exercise, but only during the workout. There is a lot that happens after the workout is over.
These studies should be taken with a grain of salt. Workouts early in the morning may cause a greater fat loss and there are many studies backing this up. However, when training on an empty stomach, the level of intensity of your workouts will be limited.
Performing high-intensity exercise in a fasted state will not be very effective, and may even be dangerous since your carbohydrate energy stores will be low, which is the primary fuel during high-intensity training.
If you have performance goals, then workouts in a fed state would be optimal for improving your performance.
Fat is utilized as energy in low-to-moderate forms of exercise, which is not the ideal type of exercise if your goal is to preserve muscle mass when exercising.
To date, the best form of cardio exercise for fat loss is high-intensity-interval-training, or HIIT. In this form of exercise, the exerciser burns more calories and fat post-workout than low-intensity exercise.
After a HIIT workout, you will burn calories for the rest of the day, even when you are sitting on your couch watching television. Not only do HIIT workouts take less time, they result in almost twice the fat loss.
Performing cardio in the fasted state may result in greater fat loss, but it is not necessary. If doing cardio first thing in the morning fits best with your schedule then go for it. However, if you would rather do your cardio later in the day, then do it later in the day.
Whether you perform cardio in the morning, afternoon, evening, etc., as long as you are consistently taking part in aerobic exercise, that is what is most important.
For optimal workout performance, I would recommend consuming some carbohydrates and protein pre-workout to give your body the fuel it needs during the workout, as well as post-workout, to give your body the ingredients necessary to replenish and repair.
About Danny Maman My name is Danny Maman. I have a real passion for health and fitness and enjoy having a life that revolves around this. I have my bachelor's degree in exercise science with a minor in allied health. I am also a certified personal trainer with ACE and am a former college basketball player.